The historical data will be present on the other webmonitor agent on the original fglam. Revert back to that one.
To keep the historical data synced up (prevent splitting off into a new topology object and starting a new data series), across the two different fglams, you need to have the 'URL' name identical and the 'Display Name' be identical between the webmonitor two agents. You can use a different 'Transaction Name' and still have the data sync up.
Note: This will not mean WebMonitorAgent supports HA. It still won't automatically fail over seamlessly to the other webmonitor agent and fglam running on the other machine.)